I actually don't really see where the hate for Yeshua comes from. I've also got the feeling that most of this debate involving Jokerman, Chronic, Glockmatic and Yeshua wasn't as much with each other but more alongside each other. The allied camp basically argued that too much of anything is bad for you, while yeshua argued that it shouldn't be a problem as long as you don't do the very things people do in the allies' examples (XTC, sporters, hazing rituals, water drinking competitions). All those instances are very specific and have nothing to do with how people live their day-to-day life.
And unless you have a consistent unhealthy living pattern, Yeshua is basically right that the body will stabilize itself over time (unless you're really unlucky).
And c'mon, in the end you people argue for the same point: that the solution to obesity and many (western world specific) health problems can be found in prevention (living healthy) rather than curing.